
Yesterday, the Puerto Rico Legislative Assembly overwhelmingly voted to pass anti-trans House Bill 164. The bill, which is known as the “Law for the Protection of Women’s Sports,” will, as the name implies, ban trans women from women’s sports. HB 164 now heads to Governor Jenniffer González-Colón’s desk, who—given her significant anti-trans record—is expected to sign it into law. When she does, Puerto Rico will join 28 US states, as well as the territory of Guam, in having passed a law or regulation banning trans athletes from women’s sports. Another state, Washington, recently enacted a ban of its own through a right-wing ballot initiative, but that is currently being challenged in court.
This isn’t the first anti-trans law Puerto Rico has passed this year, either. In February, the territory enacted an extreme law banning trans people from public bathrooms; due to Puerto Rico’s unique system, this law is more impactful than equivalent laws in other states. Indeed, both the bathroom and sports bans have the same author: Lisie J. Burgos Muñiz, who has been responsible for the vast majority of the anti-trans legislation in Puerto Rico.
As Transitics has previously reported, Muñiz is known for making some strange and extreme drafting choices in her anti-trans bills. For example, the bathroom law she authored contained language banning single-occupancy gender-neutral restrooms and humorously declared that “bathrooms don’t have sex, but people do.” Here, it’s no different.
Like the bathroom law, HB 164 opens with a lengthy legislative findings section. The first half of this section is a poorly written, 1,064-word tangent about the history of women’s sports dating back to 3000 BCE that—through its typos, lack of citations, and oversimplification—more closely resembles a middle school essay than it does a legal document. But once the summary wraps up, Muñiz immediately goes on the offensive:
“Nevertheless, over the last few years, we women have faced a new challenge due to the forced inclusion of identities and ideologies that attack the sex-based rights of women and girls. Now, men who say they identify as women are erasing and displacing the very female athletes that have fought hard for their place in Olympic, university, and school sports. It is not an insignificant fact that it’s men who are breaking women’s [sport] records and usurping first-place positions, medals, and women’s athletic glory.”
After showing an outdated map of sports bans in the US, the bill continues:
“It’s regrettable that, in the past few years, women’s sports have been threatened at the national and international level by the participation of persons of the male sex in women’s teams. This represents a disadvantage for women due to the marked physiological and biological differences between the female and male sex. It is an indisputable fact that men naturally possess higher levels of testosterone than women.”
The section then cites various academic articles and experts, but only the last of those four sources explicitly deals with trans people. Even then, that study evaluated muscle strength in trans women after one year of hormone therapy; prior to the right’s politicization of the trans sports issue, athletic federations typically required two years. Lastly, it concludes by discussing a case against Connecticut’s trans-inclusive policy that has been ongoing for the past six years. Why Muñiz did not move to amend the bill to instead discuss the recent Supreme Court ruling in B.P.J. v. West Virginia is unknown.
Finally, at the end of page 6, the law’s text begins. Here, the first four articles, as well as the seventh and eighth, aren’t new. In fact, these provisions are all largely translated from the original 2020 Idaho law that was developed by right-wing group Alliance Defending Freedom. That law currently forms the basis for 24 other states’ bans and the Washington ballot measure.
Where it gets interesting is where the HB 164 deviates: the fifth and sixth articles. In Article 5, the law makes exceptions to single-sex teams for kids aged 5–8. What makes this choice strange is that a similar carve-out only exists in five other states’ bans: Alaska, Kentucky, Tennessee, West Virginia, and Wyoming. However, the last of those bans was adopted in 2023, and the broader anti-trans sports movement seems to have moved away from acknowledging this exception. It is not clear why Muñiz chose to resurrect the provision.
Then there’s Article 6, which is titled “disputes surrounding the sex of a student.” And it reads as follows:
“Any dispute over the sex of a student athlete that arises as a result of the requirements of this law shall be resolved by the school or university the student plays under. This controversy shall be resolved in a confidential manner and in compliance with the provisions of FERPA and HIPAA. If the student athlete is a minor, the school or university shall notify their father, mother, or legal guardian and obtain their written consent guaranteeing their participation in the adjudication of the dispute. To establish their sex, the student can, in a free and voluntary manner, present to the school or university a written declaration from a doctor certifying the student’s sex. To prove the student’s sex, the doctor shall base their assessment on any of the following:
(a) The sexual and reproductive anatomy of the student;
(b) The genetic profile of the student; and
(c) The natural levels of testosterone produced by the student.
(d) A measurement of testosterone levels in nmol/L, according to internationally recognized standards.”
These requirements are identical to the Washington ballot measure, known as I-638, with the exception of the last one, which wasn’t initially present when it was introduced but was tacked on early on in its legislative journey. Another change made was that it used to require that all three things—genital status, genetic makeup, and natural testosterone production—be verified. This ‘one of the following’ approach is also employed by I-638.
Nevertheless, there are two major differences between I-638 and HB 164. The first is that, unlike I-638, the sex verification isn’t mandatory. Rather, a student must only verify their ‘biological sex’ through these methods when there is a dispute surrounding their sex. However, it places no qualifiers on what counts as a ‘dispute,’ definitively stating that “any dispute” will be resolved through this provision. Although a committee report does mention that this is meant to address instances where “legitimate doubts arise” surrounding a student’s sex, that language did not make it into the bill.
Thus, under HB 164, there is no requirement for the complaining party to substantiate their side of the dispute in any way, nor are there any limitations on who can complain. As we’ve seen with book bans, this could result in outside actors with no interest in a school’s sports program to challenge the gender of any athlete without even needing to explain why. At the same time, a student’s eligibility could be challenged by an opposing team ahead of an important game, a strategy that could be exploited by schools seeking to gain a competitive advantage.
Furthermore, it places no cap on how many times a student can be challenged, which may allow for this mechanism to be repeatedly used against certain students in order to harass them. This will likely have a disproportionate impact on girls and women who are not seen as traditionally feminine.
But more strangely, whereas the I-638 verification requirements only apply to those wishing to join girls’ sports teams, the genital inspection provision here actually applies to any gender. Indeed, instead of being required only for athletes in girls’ sports, it applies to those participating in boys’ sports teams and potentially even those in coed sports. Because of this, it won’t just be girls who will be burdened by these sex verification provisions; it’ll be everyone.
In other words, HB 164 places no limits on who can be challenged, who can challenge, what evidence someone needs to challenge, how many times someone can challenge, and how many times a person’s sex can be challenged. None of these are the case for I-638, which contains no ‘dispute’ provision and explicitly only requires the verification once.
Worst of all, it’ll go into effect immediately after the governor signs it, which means the territory’s schools truly have no way to prepare for the cascade of challenges that will arise as a result of its provisions.
Because while I-638 is certainly invasive, its drafters were fairly good at tailoring it to do exactly what they wanted: make sure every trans person is excluded from women’s sports. Meanwhile, House Bill 164 isn’t just a hateful law—it’s an excessively stupid one.
Yes, HB 164 will probably succeed in accomplishing its goal of writing trans kids out of school sports, but it is so poorly written that it may very well end up ravaging the entire Puerto Rican school sports scene in the process.
It seems this is the price that Puerto Rico is willing to pay for hate.
You can find the law, as passed, here:
Author’s note: HB 164’s original text is in Spanish. The author is a fluent Spanish speaker and has manually translated the quoted contents of the bill to English.


This is just so beyond fucked up
yikes. latin transmisogyny